Album cover. Sugar Hill / Blue Eye (SUG-CD-4007) (2005)
Track listing
- "Those Were the Days" (with special guests Mary Hopkins, Porter Wagoner & the Opry Gang, and the Moscow Circus) (Gene Raskin) – 5:00
- "Blowin' in the Wind" (with special guest Nickel Creek) (Bob Dylan) – 3:21
- "Where Have All the Flowers Gone" (with special guests Norah Jones and Lee Ann Womack) (Pete Seeger) – 4:04
- "The Twelfth of Never" (with special guest Keith Urban) (Jerry Livingston, Paul Francis Webster) – 3:16
- "Where Do the Children Play" (with special guest Yusef Islam) (Yusuf Islam) – 3:23
- "Me and Bobby McGee" (with special guest Kris Kristofferson) (Kris Kristofferson) – 3:49
- "Crimson and Clover" (with special guest Tommy James) (Tommy James, Peter P. Lucia Jr.) – 3:39
- "The Cruel War" (with special guests Alison Krauss, Mindy Smith, and Dan Tyminski) (Traditional, arr. by Dolly Parton) – 3:42
- "Turn, Turn, Turn" (with special guest Roger McGuinn) (Pete Seeger) – 3:17
- "If I Were a Carpenter" (with special guest Joe Nichols) (James Timothy Hardin) – 2:54
- "Both Sides Now" (with special guests Judy Collins and Rhonda Vincent) (Joni Mitchell) – 3:33
- "Imagine" (with special guest David Foster) (John Lennon) – 3:52
Background
While speaking at a CMA Music Festival press conference in June 2005, Dolly announced that she had been in the studio finishing up her next album and expected it to be released in October. She also stated that its title had changed from Blue Smoke to Those Were the Days and that she was in the preliminary stages of planning a tour for the fall of 2005. Dolly also confirmed that Keith Urban had recorded "The Twelfth of Never" with her for the album and that Tommy James joined her for "Crimson and Clover."
In a June 2005 article for The New York Post, gossip columnist Liz Smith published a list of guest artists for the album including Norah Jones, Sarah McLachlan, Keith Urban, Joni Mitchell, Sean Lennon, Yusef Islam, David Foster and Joe Nichols. Following the articles publication, Steve Buckingham stated that Sean Lennon, Yusuf Islam and Sarah McLachlan had been approached about recording for the project, but none had confirmed their participation. He also noted that Joni Mitchell, who was originally to appear on the album, had to cancel her recording session due to an illness in her family. The month of July also saw the confirmation of Nickel Creek, Rhonda Vincent, Kris Kristofferson, Roger McGuinn, Mary Hopkin, Alison Krauss, and Yusef Islam's participation on the album. Dolly told Jon Stewart in an interview on The Daily Show to promote the album that she had invited Bob Dylan to sing on "Blowin' in the Wind", but that he declined. She added that she was not sure whether Dylan himself declined or the refusal came from his management.
The album's original title track, "Blue Smoke," would remain unreleased until Dolly included it as the title track of her 2014 album. "I Dreamed About Elvis" was finally released in 2023 on Rockstar.
Recording
The album was recorded at Two Monkeys Studios in Nashville, Tennessee; Stir Studio in Cardiff, Wales; The Tracking Room at Masterfonics in Nashville; Dollywood's Celebrity Theater in Pigeon Forge, Tennessee; Oceanway in Nashville; Minutiae Studio in Nashville; Avatar Studios in New York City, New York; Kensal Town Studio D in London, England; No Can Beat Studios in Hana, Hawaii; Taylor Made Studios in North Caldwell, New Jersey; Sound on Sound Recording in New York City); and Chartmaker Studios in Los Angeles, California.
The title track was recorded on July 1, 2005, with Porter Wagoner, Jack Greene, George Hamilton IV, Jan Howard, George Jones, Brenda Lee, Mel McDaniel, Jimmy C. Newman, Jeannie Seely, and Billy Walker.
Dolly had previously recorded "Turn, Turn Turn" for her 1984 album, The Great Pretender.
Release and promotion
The album was released on October 11, 2005. It was reissued digitally by Dolly Records on April 10, 2020.
Singles
"Both Sides Now" with Judy Collins and Rhonda Vincent was released as the album's second single in November 2005. It went on to peak at number one on the Indie World Country Singles Chart in March 2006.
In January 2006, "The Twelfth of Never" with Keith Urban was released as a single exclusively in Urban's native Australia. The single peaked at number three on the Country Tracks Top 30 chart.
"Where Do the Children Play" was released as a single in Europe on March 20, 2006, and did not chart.
Television appearances
Tour
Critical reception
In a review for No Depression, Peter Blackstock questioned Dolly's authenticity saying that the album "seem[s] in stark contrast not just politically, but religiously" from her previous album, For God and Country. He goes on to say that it looks as if Dolly may have been "latching onto the majority support for the Iraq war shortly after it began, then turn[ed] against it in the wake of shifting public sentiment." He continues, "Yet one would think — indeed, expect — Parton is not only wiser than that, but more genuine as well. Perhaps when she affirms her devotion to both patriotism and peace, she's seeking to underscore that those notions are not mutually exclusive, despite the tendency to differentiate them in the current political climate. And maybe, when she sings John Lennon's words, she's acknowledging, in the face of her own devout faith, that it's vital to accept the differing beliefs of others." Dolly issued a statement about these criticisms in a press release prior to the album's release. She said, "It’s like [these songs] were written the day before yesterday. Whatever war it may be, someone is going off to die somewhere. I am not protesting anything. I am not political. But I am a patriot and peace-loving." Ben Ratliff of The New York Times disagreed with Blackstock's review, saying that "this is by no means a political album. But it is, among other things, a simple nostalgia album, a wartime album, a heading-toward-catastrophe album and a recollection-of-innocence album."
Writing for PopMatters, Roger Holland gave the album a mostly negative review, but scored the album seven out of ten stars. He called the title track "lettuce-limp" and said that it sounds "every bit as authentic as a three dollar bill and as much fun as a root canal in a back street dentist's office." The only songs receiving praise were "If I Were a Carpenter" which was deemed "impressive" and "Imagine," of which he said that "by the time she's finished with it, Parton has me entirely on her side. In a way, this is the story of the album as a whole." Vish Khanna of Exclaim! gave a negative review of the album, calling Dolly's take on the songs "far too Sesame Street to be taken seriously." He closed by saying that "virtually every song here would've fared better with minimal accompaniment and Parton's delicate voice."
Commercial performance
The album has sold 151,000 copies in the United States as of October 2006.
Personnel
- Dolly Parton – lead vocals, harmony vocals
- Judy Collins – special guest
- David Foster – special guest
- Mary Hopkin – special guest
- Yusuf Islam (Cat Stevens) – special guest
- Norah Jones – special guest
- Tommy Jones – special guest
- Alison Krauss – special guest
- Kris Kristofferson – special guest
- Roger McGuinn – special guest
- The Moscow Circus – special guest
- Joe Nichols – special guest
- Nickel Creek – special guest
- Sarah Watkins, Sean Watkins, Chris Thile
- The Opry Gang – special guests
- Jack Greene, George Hamilton IV, Jan Howard, George Jones, Brenda Lee, Mel McDaniel, Jimmy C. Newman, Jeannie Seely, Pam Tillis, Billy Walker
- Mindy Smith – special guest
- Dan Tyminski – special guest
- Keith Urban – special guest
- Rhonda Vincent – special guest
- Porter Wagoner – special guest
- Lee Ann Womack – special guest
- Children's choir/Kid Connection, Inc.
- Kristin Bauer, Callie Cryar, Phoebe Cryar, Katherine Stewart, Emily Webb, Anna Wilson
- Choir
- Robert Bailey, Lisa Bevill, Drew Cline, Lisa Cochran, Angela Cruz, Kim Fleming, Duane Hamilton, Vicki Hampton, John Mark Ivey
- Richard Dennison
- Terry Eldredge
- Andy Hall
- Vicki Hampton
- Jamie Johnson
- Jennifer O'Brien
- The Opry Gang
- Danny Roberts
- David Talbot
- Chuck Tille
- Kent Wells
- David Angell – strings
- Monisa Angell – strings
- Sam Bush – mandolin
- David Davidson – strings
- Richard Dennison – toy piano, Hammond B-3, Wurlitzer
- Stuart Duncan – fiddle
- Terry Eldridge – acoustic guitar
- Conni Ellisor – strings
- David Foster – piano
- Dave Fowler – bass
- Jim Grosjean – strings
- Andy Hall – dobro, harp
- Jim Hoke – harmonica
- Paul Hollowell – piano
- Tom Howard – strings
- Yusef Islam – acoustic guitar
- Tommy James – electric guitar
- Jack Jezioro – strings
- Viktor Krauss – bowed bass
- Anthony LaMarchina – strings
- Bob Mater – drums, percussion
- Jimmy Mattingly – fiddle
- Roger McGuinn – electric guitar
- Tony Rice – acoustic guitar
- Danny Roberts – mandolin
- Carole Robinowitz – strings
- Pam Sixfin – strings
- Terry Smith – bass
- Tony Smith – percussion
- Bryan Sutton – acoustic guitar
- Joey Schmidt – accordion
- David Talbot – banjo
- Chris Thile – mandolin
- Ilya Toshinsky – banjo, dulcimer, mandolika
- Alan Umstead – strings
- Catherine Umstead – strings
- Gary Vonosdale – strings
- Mary Kathryn Vonosdale - strings
- Dr. Ming Wang – Er-hu
- Jay Weaver – bass
- Kent Wells – acoustic guitar, electric guitar, 12-string accent, 6-string bass
- Penny Aust – children's choir contractor
- Brandon Bell – assistant engineer
- Courtney Blooding – assistant engineer
- Matt Boynton – engineer
- Steve Buckingham – artist coordinator
- Laurie Casteel – music copyist
- Mike Casteel – music copyist
- Steve Davis – engineer
- Neil DeVor – engineer
- Kyle Dickinson – assistant engineer
- Adam Dye – assistant engineer
- Carl Gorodetsky – strings contractor
- Leslie Hollingstad – assistant artist coordinator
- Tom Howard – choir and strings arrangements
- Tommy James – producer
- Scott Kidd – assistant engineer
- Janet McMahan – children's choir contractor
- Greg Lawrence – assistant engineer
- Patrick Murphy – engineer
- Gary Paczosa – engineer
- Dolly Parton – producer
- Kelly Pribble – engineer
- Benny Quinn – mixing engineer
- Leslie Richter – assistant engineer
- Sarah Jane Schmeltzer – engineer
- Alan Silverman – engineer
- Tony Smith – string arrangement
- Glenn M. Taylor – engineer
- Reed Taylor – second engineer
- Aya Takemura – assistant engineer
- J. Carter Tutwiler – engineer
- Sasha Vosk – director of the Moscow Circus
- Kent Wells – music coordinator
- Kristin Wilkinson – music copyist
- Jimmy Wisner – producer
- Robert Behar – Dolly's wardrobe
- Dennis Carney – photography
- Valorie Cole – make-up
- Ira Parker – artist montage compiler
- Dolly Parton – liner notes
- Cheryl Riddle – hair
- Rose Sanico – Dolly's wardrobe
- Wendy Stamberger – album package design